Canadian Forest Service Publications

Geographic scale and disturbance influence intraspecific trait variability in leaves and roots of North American understorey plants. 2019. Kumordzi, Bright B.; Aubin,Isabelle; Cardou, Françoise;Shipley, Bill; Violle, Cyrille; Johnstone, Jill; Anand, Madhur; Arsenault, André; Bell,F. Wayne; Bergeron, Yves; Boulangeat, Isabelle;Brousseau, Maxime; De Grandpré, Louis; Delagrange, Sylvain; Fenton, Nicole J.; Gravel,Dominique; Macdonald,S. Ellen; Hamel, Benoit; Higelin, Morgane; Hébert,François;Isabel, Nathalie; Mallik, Azim; McIntosh, Anne C.S.; McLaren, Jennie R.; Messier, Christian; Morris, Dave; Thiffault, Nelson; Tremblay, Jean‐Pierre; Munson, Alison D. Functional Ecology Volume 33, Issue 9 Pages 1771-1784

Year: 2019

Issued by: Atlantic Forestry Centre

Catalog ID: 39958

Language: English

Availability: PDF (request by e-mail)

Available from the Journal's Web site.
DOI: 10.1111/1365-2435.13402

† This site may require a fee

Mark record


Abstract Considering intraspecific trait variability (ITV) in ecological studies has improved our understanding of species persistence and coexistence. These advances are based on the growing number of leaf ITV studies over local gradients, but logistical constraints have prevented a solid examination of ITV in root traits or at scales reflecting species’ geographic ranges. We compared the magnitude of ITV in above‐ and below‐ground plant organs across three spatial scales (biophysical region, locality and plot). We focused on six understorey species (four herbs and two shrubs) that occur both in disturbed and undisturbed habitats across boreal and temperate Canadian forests. We aimed to document ITV structure over broad ecological and geographical scales by asking: (a) What is the breadth of ITV across species range‐scale? (b) What proportion of ITV is captured at different spatial scales, particularly when local scale disturbances are considered? and (c) Is the variance structure consistent between analogous leaf and root traits, and between morphological and chemical traits? Following standardized methods, we sampled 818 populations across 79 forest plots simultaneously, including disturbed and undisturbed stands, spanning four biophysical regions (~5,200 km). Traits measured included specific leaf area (SLA), specific root length (SRL) and leaf and root nutrient concentrations (N, P, K, Mg, Ca). We used variance decomposition techniques to characterize ITV structure across scales. Our results show that an important proportion of ITV occurred at the local scale when sampling included contrasting environmental conditions resulting from local disturbance. A certain proportion of the variability in both leaf and root traits remained unaccounted for by the three sampling scales included in the design (36% on average), with the largest amount for SRL (54%). Substantial differences in magnitude of ITV were found among the six species, and between analogous traits, suggesting that trait distribution was influenced by species strategy and reflects the extent of understorey environment heterogeneity. Even for species with broad geographical distributions, a large proportion of within‐species trait variability can be captured by sampling locally across ecological gradients. This has practical implications for sampling design and trait selection for both local studies and continental‐scale modelling.

Plain Language Summary

Our collaborative study investigates variability in leaf and root characteristics for six widely distributed understory forest plant species in Canada. Understory species play an integral role in ecosystem processes, especially in northern forest ecosystems. Within a given species, high variability of characteristics such as specific leaf area (leaf area per unit weight) enables adaptation to a wide range of environmental conditions and levels of resource availability (light, soil nutrients etc). We enlisted and coordinated the efforts of 23 research teams across Canada to sample 79 sites in July 2014 (from Newfoundland to Yukon), covering four biophysical regions (about 5000 km). When comparing between areas, variability in plant characteristics decreases with increasing study scale, with most variability captured within localities of similar climate and soil conditions. Site disturbances such as fire or harvest (i.e. logging) explained a large proportion of variability in plant characteristics, for both leaves and roots. Our study suggests that even for a species occurring across a wide geographical range, most variability can be found within local populations when local scale disturbances are consider. This has practical implications for sampling design for both local studies and continental scale modelling.